Is K-Pop Survival Going Too Far? 7 Reasons "Boys II Planet" Has Fans Worried!
- Disha Paul
- Jul 30
- 3 min read
The debut of Boys II Planet has sparked more than just excitement—it has triggered serious concern among fans. Episode 1 revealed a survival show that feels more punishing than uplifting, raising questions about whether this format has gone too far.
Audiences expected talent and growth but instead encountered forced drama, grueling tasks, and heavy-handed editing. Here is a breakdown of the most pressing issues.
Queerbaiting and Forced Fanservice
The show’s early clips featured blindfolded contestants pressed together for guessing games. Many viewers criticized this setup as staged fanservice aimed at generating buzz without genuine context. Comments like “it feels too forced” appeared across social media, suggesting fans are losing interest in artificial drama.
Uneven Screen Time and Manipulative Editing
Certain trainees received over 15 minutes of screen time, while others barely appeared at all. The uneven spotlight led to accusations of manipulative editing tactics designed to heighten conflict rather than show true talent.
Fans pointed out that the most skilled performers were often ignored, fueling frustration among viewers.
Controversy Surrounding Kim Geon-woo
The inclusion of trainee Kim Geon-woo stirred controversy even before the premiere. Allegations surfaced accusing him of bullying and abusing his power at a former agency.
Despite these serious claims, Mnet kept him in the lineup, stating investigations were ongoing. His prominent position in Episode 1 left fans questioning the show’s ethics.
The ‘Death Mission’ and Trainee Burnout
One of the episode’s most shocking moments involved what fans are calling the "death mission." Trainees had to repeat choreography over thirty times until one collapsed from exhaustion.
Social media reactions noted this felt less like training and more like deliberate physical punishment. Viewers expressed concern for the mental and physical health of the participants.
Vocal Editing and Lip-Syncing Concerns
Viewers noticed heavy vocal editing and auto-tune in performance segments. Fans questioned how judges or viewers could assess true vocal ability when the real voices were hidden behind effects.
Comments asking “what is the point if we cannot hear their true talent” appeared across forums.
Popularity Over Skill?
The show’s format allows popularity-based rankings to influence screen time. Observers pointed out that trainees with large existing fanbases seemed favored, while skilled performers without big followings were sidelined. Critics argue this rewards popularity over genuine potential.
Peak Time as a Contrast
Viewers frequently compare Boys II Planet unfavorably with Peak Time, a show widely praised for fair editing and genuine storytelling. Unlike Boys II Planet, Peak Time gave eliminated contestants respectful treatment and balanced screen time. Many believe this is the direction survival shows should take.
Viewer Reactions Speak Out
Forums like Reddit and fan communities have been filled with strong reactions: “Survival shows drain the life out of all of us. Winners feel pre-picked", and “Too many shows now rely on gossipy editing rather than talent.” Such feedback shows a growing demand for formats that support both artistry and well-being.
Episode 1 Recap: Highlights and Concerns
Episode 1 brought high-energy auditions and dramatic eliminations. The “death mission” emphasized physical resilience over creative skill, while editing highlighted conflict over character development. Still, a few trainees managed to shine, drawing cautious hopes that talent may survive the cutthroat format.
Where to Watch Episode 2
Episode 2 aired on July 24 at 9:20 PM KST for Planet K and July 25 at the same time for Planet C. Episodes are available on Mnet’s official platforms, where viewers often follow and debate outcomes in real time.
Final Thoughts
Episode 1 of Boys II Planet raised important questions. Is this show about discovering talent or just testing endurance? Without a shift in focus, fans fear the format will continue to favor conflict and popularity over authenticity and care.
Was Episode 1 unfair, or did your favorite trainee shine through? Share your thoughts below and join the discussion.
Comments